Skip to main content

Gavin Polone’s Claims About Israel: Setting the Historical Record Straight

A magnifying glass over a handwritten 1937 letter, a historic photo of a village, and a film strip, illustrating an examination of Gavin Polone's claims about Israel

GAVIN POLONE’S CLAIMS ABOUT ISRAEL: SETTING THE HISTORICAL RECORD STRAIGHT

Recently, Hollywood producer Gavin Polone published a social media post asserting that Israel’s founding was “ALWAYS about the ethnic cleansing of the indigenous population.” To support this claim, he pointed his followers to three sources: a 1937 letter from David Ben-Gurion, the documentary Tantura, and the recent documentary NAZA, which accuses Israeli military personnel of deliberately killing Palestinian civilians.

These are serious allegations, yet the sources Polone recommends present highly contested claims while omitting critical historical evidence and context.

Given the influence of public figures within the entertainment industry, Creative Community for Peace believes it is essential that artists, executives, and other industry professionals have access to a more complete and accurate understanding of these issues.

Below, we examine each of Polone’s three claims, providing historical documentation, scholarly research, and additional sources that challenge his assertions and offer readers a broader understanding of the historical record.

1. DAVID BEN-GURION AND HIS 1937 LETTER

The passages Polone’s post quotes from Ben-Gurion’s 1937 letter to his son Amos are frequently used to argue that Zionism was founded on a plan to expel the Arab population. But they are presented without the historical circumstances in which the letter was written, much of what Ben-Gurion actually said in the same document, or his subsequent statements and actions.

The letter was written in October 1937, during debates over the British Peel Commission’s proposal to partition Mandatory Palestine into separate Jewish and Arab states. Ben-Gurion supported accepting a Jewish state on a relatively small portion of the land, while his son opposed partition. Arab political leaders rejected the proposal outright. Ben-Gurion’s argument was that establishing a Jewish state, even within limited borders, would provide the security, political independence, and resources needed to absorb Jewish refugees and build a viable national homeland. This was taking place as Jewish persecution in Europe was accelerating and the need for a secure refuge was becoming increasingly urgent.

Ben-Gurion certainly hoped for greater Jewish settlement throughout the historic Land of Israel than what the Peel Commission was offering, but he was willing to accept it. He also considered the possibility of using force if attacked by the Arabs, which isn’t surprising.

Keep in mind that this was also during the Great Arab Revolt, which began in 1936 and saw Arab militants unleash waves of violence against Jews and the British. Jewish communities, civilians, and transportation routes were attacked, while the revolt’s leadership demanded an end to Jewish immigration. The violence followed earlier anti-Jewish attacks, including the 1929 Hebron massacre, in which 67 Jews were murdered and a centuries-old Jewish community was devastated. The United States Holocaust Memorial Museum’s historical account documents the Arab Revolt and the role played by the Arab Higher Committee under Haj Amin al-Husseini, the Grand Mufti of Jerusalem.

Ben-Gurion also entertained population-transfer proposals during this period, but not in the way Polone’s post is describing them. Population exchanges were hardly unique to Zionism in an era when the great empires were breaking apart and new states were being created. The British Peel Commission itself proposed population transfers, citing the population exchange between Greece and Turkey in 1923 as a precedent. A decade later, the partition of British India into India and Pakistan was accompanied by enormous population movements involving millions of people.

Those facts belong in any serious examination of his thinking. Yet the very letter Polone’s post cites contains extensive passages envisioning cooperation with neighboring Arabs, negotiated settlement, and mutual economic development. He described Jews and Arabs becoming allies and expressed his hope that war could be avoided.

There is also great dispute concerning another passage in the same letter, frequently circulated as evidence of Ben-Gurion’s support for expulsion. The original handwritten document contains crossed-out words that reverse the meaning of the familiar quotation. The Ben-Gurion Heritage Institute presents the passage as expressing his opposition to expelling Arabs, stating that there was sufficient room for both peoples.

Historian Benny Morris and Ben-Gurion’s biographers have examined this controversy, while a detailed comparison of the original manuscript and English translations identifies additional translation errors, including words inserted into a published version that do not appear in the original Hebrew.

Perhaps even more revealing is what Ben-Gurion said ten years later, shortly before Israel’s establishment. In July 1947, he appeared before the United Nations Special Committee on Palestine and explicitly recognized the rights of the existing Arab population to the land. He told the committee, “We do not claim that any Arab ought to be removed.” He also spoke about the necessity of cooperation between Jews and Arabs. People can read his remarks in this reproduction of his 1947 testimony.

Compare Ben-Gurion’s words with what leading Arab figures were saying during precisely this period.

In October 1947, Arab League Secretary-General Abdul Rahman Azzam Pasha warned that the coming conflict would be a “war of extermination and momentous massacre.” The statement was published in the Egyptian newspaper Akhbar al-Yom on October 11, 1947. Historian Efraim Karsh subsequently located the original contemporary newspaper account, establishing the authenticity of a quotation, as the anti-Israel movement has tried to rewrite history and erase quotes like this from the historical record.

On November 24, 1947, Jamal al-Husseini, representing the Arab Higher Committee, warned the United Nations that the proposed partition boundary would become a “line of fire and blood.” His words appear in the official UN meeting record. The following year, Haj Amin al-Husseini was reported as declaring that the Arabs would continue fighting until the Zionists were annihilated and all of Palestine became an Arab state. The Grand Mufti had already spent World War II collaborating with Nazi Germany, spreading antisemitic propaganda and advocating violence against Jews, as documented by the United States Holocaust Memorial Museum.

These were prominent Arab political leaders openly threatening war, destruction, and the elimination of Jewish national sovereignty throughout Palestine. Their statements and the violence already underway are essential context for understanding Ben-Gurion’s concerns about Jewish security and survival.

And when war ultimately came in 1948, the Israeli government and military expressly issued orders restricting the expulsion of Arab civilians. On July 4, 1948, with the war raging after the invasion by neighboring Arab states and Israel fighting for its survival, the government committee responsible for abandoned property issued an order, subsequently circulated as an official military directive on July 6, prohibiting the destruction of Arab communities or the expulsion of their inhabitants outside active combat without specific authorization from the minister of defense, Ben-Gurion. Violations could lead to prosecution. Historians Alon Kadish and Avraham Sela document these orders in their archival study, Myths and Historiography of the 1948 Palestine War Revisited.

In a November 1948 cabinet discussion, Ben-Gurion explicitly opposed driving Arab residents from their homes, stating, “There is no need to chase them away.” These were statements made during the war itself, when Israel was fighting invading Arab armies and confronting serious threats to its civilian population.

Meanwhile, Arab forces were carrying out the expulsion and destruction of Jewish communities in the territories they captured. When Jordan’s Arab Legion conquered Jerusalem’s Old City in May 1948, the Jewish Quarter surrendered, its surviving Jewish residents were removed, and hundreds of defenders were taken prisoner. The ancient Jewish community was emptied, and its synagogues and religious institutions suffered extensive destruction. These events are documented in a contemporaneous U.S. State Department diplomatic report dated May 29, 1948.

Jewish communities in Gush Etzion were similarly overrun, with defenders killed, including after surrender, and the surviving residents of other settlements evacuated. Jewish settlements at Atarot, Neve Yaakov, and Beit HaArava were also destroyed or abandoned during the fighting. By the end of the war, the territories that came under Jordanian control, including the West Bank and East Jerusalem, had been emptied of their established Jewish communities.

Israel’s Declaration of Independence, which Ben-Gurion read on May 14, 1948, promised equal social and political rights to all inhabitants, regardless of religion, race, or sex. Approximately 150,000 Arabs remained in Israel after the war and became citizens of the new state.

The historical record reveals a leader pursuing Jewish national self-determination under extraordinarily difficult circumstances, confronting decades of anti-Jewish violence, explicit threats of destruction, and ultimately a war launched to prevent the establishment of a Jewish state. Selected quotations from a private letter cannot establish that the original purpose of the Jewish state was the systematic removal of an entire population. That conclusion overlooks substantial evidence, including Ben-Gurion’s own words, Israeli government directives, and the historical circumstances in which these decisions were made.

For further reading, we recommend the Ben-Gurion Heritage Institute’s archival material, the examination of the original 1937 manuscript and its mistranslations, his 1947 testimony before the United Nations, the research into Arab League threats preceding the 1948 war, and the archival study documenting Israel’s July 1948 military directives.

2. TANTURA AND THE 1948 WAR

The documentary Tantura is another example of a film presenting a deeply contested historical allegation with a degree of certainty that the underlying evidence does not justify.

To understand Tantura, we first have to understand the war in which it occurred.

On November 29, 1947, the United Nations voted to partition British Mandatory Palestine into two states, one Jewish and one Arab. Jewish leaders accepted the proposal. Arab leaders rejected it. Fighting broke out immediately afterward, with Palestinian Arab irregulars and other Arab forces attacking Jewish communities, transportation routes, and settlements. The conflict escalated into a civil war.

On May 14, 1948, Israel declared independence. The following day, armies from neighboring Arab countries invaded the former Mandate. The contemporary New York Times headline on May 16, 1948, was unequivocal, “Arab Armies Invade Palestine; Reach Gaza, Bomb Tel Aviv Again.” The U.S. State Department’s historical account confirms this chronology and the Arab leadership’s efforts to prevent the establishment of a Jewish state.

The approximately 700,000 Palestinians who became refugees did so in the course of a war that followed the rejection of partition and the attempt to prevent Israel’s establishment by force. Many fled as war was imminent, many others fled at the urging of Arab leaders to get out of the way of advancing Arab armies, and others due to fighting and fear. Historian Efraim Karsh documents evacuation instructions issued by Arab leaders in places including Haifa, Jerusalem, and other communities during the war. Others were expelled by Jewish and Israeli forces, often from cities where fierce fighting occurred. Israel subsequently prevented most refugees from returning.

Former Syrian Prime Minister Khalid al-Azm acknowledged in his memoirs that Arab governments had encouraged Palestinians to leave, writing, “But we ourselves are the ones who encouraged them to leave.” Even Mahmoud Abbas, writing in the PLO’s official journal in March 1976, acknowledged that Arab armies had “forced them to emigrate and to leave their homeland.”

Similarly, approximately 850,000 Jews were driven from or fled Arab countries in the decades surrounding Israel’s establishment. During the 1948 war, Jewish communities were also expelled or destroyed in areas conquered by Jordan and Egypt, including the ancient Jewish Quarter of Jerusalem’s Old City.

The danger to these ancient Jewish communities across the Middle East and North Africa was already being documented at the time. On May 16, 1948, The New York Times warned that nearly 900,000 Jews across Arab and Muslim lands faced grave danger, reporting persecution, threats of confiscation, and restrictions on Jewish communities from North Africa to the Middle East.

It was also a brutal war in which atrocities and massacres occurred on both sides.

On April 13, 1948, Arab fighters ambushed a medical convoy traveling to Hadassah Hospital on Mount Scopus, killing 78 people, including doctors, nurses, and medical personnel. A contemporaneous communication to the United Nations documents the attack. On May 13, Arab forces overran Kfar Etzion, where defenders were killed, including after surrender. Approximately 127 Jewish defenders died. The history of the battle and massacre is well documented.

Jewish forces also committed atrocities, including at Deir Yassin, where approximately 100 Palestinian Arabs were killed, and in other incidents during the war. Historian Benny Morris has documented these events extensively.

Acknowledging the crimes committed during the war is essential to understanding its history. So is recognizing the circumstances in which the war began and the violence directed against Jewish communities.

Tantura itself was captured by the Alexandroni Brigade during fighting on May 22 and 23, 1948. The documentary resurrects allegations originally advanced by Teddy Katz, whose thesis claimed that Israeli soldiers systematically massacred approximately 200 to 250 villagers after the battle.

Those allegations have been challenged by Benny Morris, one of the leading historians of the 1948 war and a scholar who has extensively documented Israeli expulsions and atrocities.

Morris identified serious discrepancies between Katz’s recorded interviews and the quotations attributed to witnesses in his thesis. He also noted that contemporary Israeli military records, UN and Red Cross documentation, and early Palestinian historical accounts failed to report a massacre on the scale alleged. Even Palestinian historian Walid Khalidi, whose work documents the destruction and depopulation of Palestinian villages, did not identify a mass killing of that magnitude in his account of Tantura.

A former Tantura resident who published a history of the village in 1998 listed 52 people killed during the events of May 1948, considerably fewer than Katz alleged. Morris acknowledges evidence that Israeli soldiers committed unlawful killings after the battle, while disputing the claim of a systematic massacre of hundreds.

The controversy over Katz’s research also led to a defamation lawsuit brought by Alexandroni veterans. Katz signed a retraction, subsequently withdrew it, and his work came under severe academic scrutiny. The lawsuit did not conclusively determine the historical facts, but the documented discrepancies in the testimony remain important.

More recent aerial-image research has identified possible mass-grave sites at Tantura. The presence of wartime burial sites cannot, by itself, establish how the people buried there died or prove that hundreds of surrendered civilians were systematically executed. In fact, Morris directly addressed these new allegations in May 2023, explaining that evidence of mass graves proves nothing about the number of people killed or the circumstances of their deaths. He reiterated that the claim of an organized, systematic massacre of 200 to 250 villagers lacked persuasive evidence.

His detailed analysis is available in The Tantura ‘Massacre’ Affair, and he returned to the subject in his 2022 critique of the documentary.

The refugee crisis and the suffering of Palestinian civilians deserve serious historical examination. A documentary that presents disputed testimony while omitting the wider war, the atrocities committed against Jews, and the evidence challenging its central allegation gives viewers a profoundly incomplete understanding of 1948.

For further reading, we recommend Morris’s investigation of the Tantura allegations, his later assessment of the documentary, Efraim Karsh’s research into Arab evacuation orders, and the U.S. State Department’s history of the 1948 Arab-Israeli War.

3. NAZA AND ITS ALLEGATIONS AGAINST THE IDF

Polone’s recommendation of NAZA is especially troubling given the serious questions raised about the film’s evidence, editing, translations, and portrayal of Israeli military procedures.

Creative Community for Peace recently published an extensive, sourced examination of the film, NAZA: A Tale of Lies – How the Documentary Misled Audiences. We strongly encourage people to read it before recommending the film further.

The documentary relies on 24 anonymous speakers presented as Israeli soldiers and intelligence personnel. Their faces and voices are concealed, and the film generally provides little information establishing their precise roles, authority, or firsthand knowledge of the incidents they describe.

Despite making extraordinary allegations of deliberate civilian killing, the film provides no identifiable strikes, dates, locations, target names, operational orders, or military records that would allow viewers to independently verify its most serious claims.

The filmmakers also failed to submit their allegations to the IDF for comment before the film’s release, a basic safeguard in investigative reporting. The film has been criticized for these omissions by journalists who examined its methodology.

Even the English subtitles materially change some of the testimony.

In one prominent example, an anonymous speaker’s uncertain claim about an approval involving approximately 500 people is transformed into a more definitive subtitle describing approval to kill 500 civilians for one target. The film provides no corresponding incident, strike record, or evidence that 500 civilians were actually killed in such an attack.

In another instance, a statement referring to a man and his family is subtitled to add that the entire family will die, words absent from the spoken Hebrew. These discrepancies are documented in an independent examination of the film’s journalistic shortcomings.

The film also fundamentally misrepresents how military targeting decisions are made.

Intelligence analysts collect and evaluate information. They do not independently authorize airstrikes. Target verification, operational planning, estimates of civilian harm, legal assessment, and command authorization are separate stages of the process. Yet the film repeatedly presents accounts from individuals working at one stage as definitive descriptions of the entire process.

The documentary also portrays temporary civilian-risk thresholds as standing permission to kill a specified number of civilians. In reality, the IDF maintains that these thresholds determined the level of authorization required and that individual strikes still underwent proportionality assessments and operational review. The military says the elevated threshold discussed in the film was reduced in November 2023 and tightened further in January 2024.

Similarly, the film’s portrayal of the Lavender intelligence database as an autonomous killing system ignores the distinction between an intelligence-support tool and the human decisions required to authorize a strike.

These issues are examined in the IDF’s detailed official response, as well as Yair Miron’s examination of eleven ways the documentary misleads viewers. Miron is an IDF reserve lieutenant colonel who has worked in intelligence-related command roles.

There is another omission that fundamentally distorts the audience’s understanding of the war.

The conflict began with Hamas’s October 7, 2023 massacre, when terrorists invaded Israel, murdered approximately 1,200 people, and abducted 251 hostages. Hamas subsequently fought from an extensive military infrastructure embedded within Gaza’s civilian environment, including tunnels, residential areas, and other protected or densely populated locations.

These circumstances created enormous challenges for distinguishing combatants from civilians and evaluating potential civilian casualties. The film offers little meaningful examination of those realities or of Israel’s procedures for assessing civilian harm.

Estimating potential civilian casualties before an attack is a requirement of the laws of war. The existence of such assessments is not proof of an intention to murder civilians. Each incident requires examination of the military objective, the information available, the precautions taken, and the proportionality assessment.

The allegations in NAZA deserve serious scrutiny. That scrutiny should apply equally to the documentary’s own reporting, especially when it accuses an entire military of deliberately murdering innocent people.

For further reading, we encourage people to begin with CCFP’s comprehensive NAZA rebuttal. CCFP has also prepared a detailed sourced one-pager and a shorter summary of the key issues. Additional perspectives include John Spencer’s analysis of the documentary, Yair Miron’s firsthand examination of military procedures, and the IDF’s formal response.

FINALLY

The history of Israel and the Palestinians contains genuine tragedies, competing national aspirations, and decisions that deserve serious criticism.

But historical arguments should be grounded in evidence, and allegations as serious as systematic ethnic cleansing and deliberate mass murder demand especially rigorous scrutiny. Anti-Israel activist groups and filmmakers should not be relied upon for an accurate accounting of this history.

What troubles us most is that Polone’s post reaches people who may have very little knowledge of this history and who may take his recommendations as authoritative. When he states that the founding of Israel was always about ethnic cleansing and recommends these films as definitive proof, he is presenting highly contested interpretations as settled fact.

There is a responsibility that comes with speaking publicly about a subject this consequential, especially at a time when misinformation about Israel and the Jewish people is contributing to growing hostility and antisemitism.

X
Send this to a friend