Skip to main content
All Posts By

CCFPeace

NAZA: A Tale of Lies – How the Documentary Misled Audiences

NAZA: A Tale of Lies cover: how an anti-Israel documentary manipulated testimony, distorted military procedures, and misled audiences

NAZA: A Tale of Lies cover, how an anti-Israel documentary manipulated testimony, distorted military procedures, and misled audiences

This article is also available as a visual carousel on Instagram: view it on Instagram.

NAZA: A TALE OF LIES

How an anti-Israel documentary manipulated testimony, distorted military procedures, and misled audiences.

The documentary NAZA makes explosive accusations against Israel, including allegations of war crimes and genocide. But behind its claims lies a troubling pattern of anonymous speakers, manipulated subtitles, distorted military procedures, and critical facts deliberately left out.

The film ignores Hamas’s role in the war, misrepresents Israel’s efforts to minimize civilian casualties, and presents allegations as established facts without the evidence to substantiate them.

This is propaganda masquerading as investigative journalism.

We examine what the filmmakers chose to show, what they chose to hide, and how they manipulated the narrative.

NAZA MAKES EXPLOSIVE ACCUSATIONS WITH NO VERIFIABLE EVIDENCE

The film accuses Israel of operating an automated system for killing civilians in Gaza.

Yet throughout its 80 minutes, the film provides no specific dates, locations, target names, military orders, or operational records that allow viewers to independently verify its most serious accusations.

NO DATES. NO LOCATIONS. NO TARGET NAMES. NO MILITARY ORDERS. NO STRIKE RECORDS.

The film asks audiences to believe allegations they cannot independently examine and that the film never substantiates.

24 ANONYMOUS SPEAKERS. ZERO VERIFIABLE STRIKE DETAILS.

NAZA builds its case around 24 anonymous speakers, shown in silhouette with digitally altered voices.

For most, the film provides no clear rank, military role, or information establishing firsthand knowledge of the events they describe.

Their testimonies concern different subjects and different stages of military operations. None of them even verify each other’s stories.

The filmmakers offer no way to independently test their most explosive allegations.

24 hidden faces. Zero identified strikes.

NAZA PORTRAYS ITS ANONYMOUS SPEAKERS AS LEFT-WING ISRAELIS TO SELL THE GENOCIDE ACCUSATION

The film portrays its anonymous intelligence personnel as educated, left-leaning Israelis who allegedly participated in war crimes.

The message is calculated. The film portrays even Israel’s most liberal citizens as complicit in genocide.

Yet the film never establishes the political leanings of these 24 individuals, their authority within the military, or how much of the decision-making process they actually observed.

Their supposed political leanings are used to trick audiences into believing that all Israelis are evil.

As examined in The Times of Israel’s investigation, the film stereotypes Intelligence Corps soldiers as elitist left-wingers who allegedly participated in war crimes.

NAZA’S SUBTITLES ADD WORDS ITS ANONYMOUS SPEAKERS NEVER SAID

In one of NAZA’s most inflammatory scenes, a speaker says the following in Hebrew, translated into English:

What was actually said

“There was an approval of, like, 500 for a single person.”

What viewers were shown

“There was approval once to kill 500 for one human target.”

The subtitle removes the speaker’s uncertainty and adds words he never said.

In another example, a reference to “Ahmad and his entire family” becomes “Ahmad and his entire family will die.”

The changes substantially alter the meaning of the testimony.

THE GUARDIAN HELPED PRODUCE A FILM THAT BROKE ITS OWN JOURNALISTIC STANDARDS

The Guardian’s editorial code requires rigorous corroboration of anonymous allegations and efforts to obtain a response from the accused.

NAZA’s filmmakers failed to present their allegations to the IDF before releasing the film.

They withheld the supporting records from viewers.

They used anonymous accusations to level the gravest possible charges while preventing independent scrutiny.

The filmmakers hide behind The Guardian’s reputation, while The Guardian lends its credibility to a film that violates its own journalistic standards.

The IDF’s official response states that the filmmakers chose not to submit their allegations for examination before publication.

VENICE GAVE NAZA A RECORD 24½ MINUTES. BUT APPLAUSE DOES NOT MAKE THE LIES TRUE.

At the 2026 Venice Film Festival, the marketers of NAZA orchestrated a record-breaking standing ovation as part of their propaganda.

The applause generated international headlines and helped give the film an aura of credibility.

Yet a manufactured standing ovation cannot verify anonymous testimony, correct altered subtitles, or substantiate egregious allegations.

24½ minutes of applause. Zero evidence supporting its claims.

INTELLIGENCE ANALYSTS DO NOT ORDER AIRSTRIKES

NAZA presents intelligence personnel with limited knowledge of the military’s full targeting and approval process as authorities on that entire process.

Unit 8200 analysts do not authorize airstrikes.

Intelligence gathering is only one stage.

Target verification, operational planning, civilian-harm assessments, legal review, and command authorization take place through additional stages.

The military approval process includes intelligence data, target verification, civilian-harm assessment, operational and legal review, and a commander’s decision.

The film presents fragments of the process as the full picture while concealing the IDF’s actual review and approval protocols.

500 CIVILIANS FOR ONE TARGET? NO EVIDENCE. NO IDENTIFIED STRIKE.

NAZA’s most explosive claim alleges that Israel approved killing 500 civilians to eliminate a single Hamas target. That never occurred.

The film provides no date, location, target name, or operational record.

Even the anonymous speaker admits he does not know how many people were actually killed, and neither Hamas nor any media outlet has claimed that a single strike killed anywhere near 500 people.

The IDF categorically states it never planned, approved, or carried out a strike anticipating 500 civilian deaths.

The allegation was featured prominently in the trailer despite the absence of any supporting evidence.

NAZA TURNED A MILITARY SAFEGUARD INTO A LICENSE TO KILL

NAZA portrays a civilian-risk threshold of 20 as standing permission to kill 20 civilians for every low-level Hamas operative.

A civilian-risk threshold determines which level of command must approve a strike. It does not automatically authorize an attack.

Every strike requires an individual assessment.

The film also leaves out a critical part of the timeline.

The elevated threshold lasted roughly one month before being cut in half on November 5, 2023, and tightened further in January 2024.

In October 2023, the IDF operated under an elevated wartime approval threshold.

On November 5, 2023, the threshold was reduced from 20 to 10.

Restrictions tightened further in January 2024.

20 was never a kill quota.

NAZA CLAIMS AI DECIDED WHO LIVED AND WHO DIED

The film portrays the military’s Lavender intelligence database as an autonomous killing machine.

Lavender is an intelligence-support tool.

The database assists human analysts in reviewing intelligence.

It does not independently authorize airstrikes.

It does not determine whether a target is attacked.

Human intelligence officers and operational commanders make those decisions through a multistage approval process.

Even the film’s own anonymous speakers acknowledge that human officers made firing decisions. NAZA obfuscates this critical fact.

AI never had strike authority.

THE FILM INVENTS 80 CIVILIAN DEATHS WITH A MATH EQUATION

An anonymous speaker uses an evacuation map to estimate how many people might have remained in eight buildings after evacuation.

He assumes eight apartments per building, with five people in each apartment. He then assumes that 25% of the original residents remained.

8 buildings × 8 apartments × 5 people × 25% = 80

He then treats those 80 estimated remaining residents as 80 people killed, without establishing how many people actually remained or whether any of them died.

The map’s green designation actually represents an estimated occupancy range of 0% to 25%.

That includes completely empty buildings.

80 estimated residents ≠ 80 verified deaths.

No identified strike. No verified casualties. Just an assumed percentage turned into a death toll.

NAZA SHOWS ISRAELIS LIVING NORMAL LIVES WHILE HIDING A NATION TRAUMATIZED BY WAR

NAZA repeatedly cuts from destruction in Gaza to Israelis going about ordinary routines, portraying a nation indifferent to Palestinian suffering.

In reality, Israelis were mourning the October 7 massacre, fighting to bring back 251 hostages, and living through rocket attacks, ballistic missile attacks, drone strikes, and repeated reserve call-ups.

Approximately 253,000 Israelis had been evacuated from their homes by November 1, 2023.

The psychological toll on soldiers was also immense.

In October 2026, Israel’s Defense Ministry reported that more than 30,000 wounded soldiers and security personnel had sought rehabilitation since October 7.

Of those receiving treatment, 63% were receiving care for psychological conditions, including PTSD.

NAZA edits that national trauma out of the picture.

NAZA IGNORES OCTOBER 7 AND HAMAS’ MASSACRE OF ISRAELIS

NAZA addresses October 7 briefly before shifting its focus to accusations against Israel.

The film doesn’t give viewers any sense of Hamas’s long history of attacks against Israel or the military threat Israel faced.

Hamas launched wars against Israel in 2008-2009, 2012, 2014, and 2021.

Then, on October 7, 2023, Hamas-led terrorists invaded Israel, murdered approximately 1,200 people, and abducted 251 hostages.

Hamas tried to carry out a genocide on October 7th. It was the deadliest attack against Jews since the Holocaust.

NAZA strips away this history and presents Israel’s military response without explaining the enemy it was fighting or the war Hamas unleashed.

NAZA IGNORES HOW HAMAS FOUGHT THE WAR USING CIVILIANS AS HUMAN SHIELDS

Hamas embedded military operations within Gaza’s civilian environment.

Hamas placed command posts, weapons, tunnel entrances, and military positions in residential buildings, mosques, schools, tent encampments, and other densely populated areas.

The terrorist organization constructed an extensive underground network, estimated at 350 to 450 miles of Hamas terror tunnels, with thousands of tunnel shafts and booby-trapped structures.

This battlefield reality directly affected target verification, civilian-risk calculations, evacuation warnings, and military planning.

NAZA presents the consequences of urban warfare while obscuring Hamas’s military strategy that saw its own people’s deaths as a strategy, not a tragedy.

NAZA PORTRAYS SAFEGUARDS AS EVIDENCE OF WAR CRIMES

Civilian-harm assessments are a requirement of the laws of war.

They allow commanders to evaluate anticipated civilian harm before deciding whether to authorize an attack.

That process can lead to additional precautions, changes to the strike plan, higher levels of approval, or cancellation of the strike.

NAZA turns a system designed to assess and reduce civilian risk into an accusation of deliberate killing.

NAZA CLAIMS CIVILIAN-HARM ASSESSMENTS PROVE GENOCIDE. BUT IT ACTUALLY UNDERCUTS THE FILM’S OWN ACCUSATIONS.

The film portrays Israel’s system of estimating potential civilian casualties before military strikes as evidence of a deliberate policy to kill Palestinians.

But calculating civilian risk, requiring command approval, involving military lawyers, and modifying or canceling strikes are measures designed to reduce civilian harm.

These procedures are part of the laws of war.

Genocide requires specific intent to destroy, in whole or in part, a national, ethnic, racial, or religious group.

The film attempts to turn procedures for limiting civilian harm into proof of that intent.

The very existence of these safeguards undermines NAZA’s central claim that Israel’s objective was the destruction of the Palestinian people.

Where is the proof of genocidal intent?

MORE THAN 6,000 LEADERS REJECT THE GENOCIDE LIE

In September 2026, Creative Community for Peace brought together more than 6,000 leaders from entertainment, academia, government, business, and public life to reject the accusation that Israel committed genocide in Gaza.

Signatories included Boris Johnson, Deborah Lipstadt, Steven Pinker, Irwin Cotler, Sherry Lansing, Debra Messing, and thousands of others.

The letter explains the legal distinction that NAZA ignores.

Genocide requires specific intent to destroy a people. Civilian casualties do not establish that intent.

The signatories also warned that the accusation has been weaponized to fuel antisemitism around the world.

NAZA promotes a genocide accusation that CCFP and thousands of leaders have publicly rejected.

Read the CCFP open letter and announcement rejecting the genocide accusation.

NAZA DISTORTED THE FACTS TO DEMONIZE ISRAEL

The film’s case depends on a series of distortions.

Anonymous allegations without verifiable strike details.

English subtitles that add words never spoken.

Temporary risk thresholds portrayed as permanent killing quotas.

Intelligence tools portrayed as autonomous weapons.

Incomplete testimony presented as military policy.

Civilian-harm safeguards reframed as deliberate killing.

NAZA asks viewers to accept its accusations while withholding the evidence needed to substantiate them.

A DOCUMENTARY SHOULD PRESENT EVIDENCE. NAZA CONCOCTS A NARRATIVE.

The film makes outrageous accusations while hiding the facts.

Before accepting its conclusions, examine the testimony, the translations, the military procedures, and the evidence it chose to leave out.

AUDIENCES DESERVE THE TRUTH.

CCFP STATEMENT ON SHAWN MENDES’ COMMENTS ABOUT GAZA

Shawn Mendes says he has been educating himself about the Israeli-Palestinian conflict. Unfortunately, his recent statement suggests that his education has been deeply biased and one-sided.

By accusing Israel of genocide, Shawn is repeating a dangerous lie propagated by Hamas and rooted in Soviet-era propaganda. Recently, Creative Community for Peace released an open letter signed by more than 6,000 leaders and public figures from across entertainment, academia, government, religion, and public life, rejecting this accusation and warning of its role in fueling antisemitism worldwide.

Words matter. Especially when they come from an artist with nearly 70 million followers on social media.

Extremist accusations against Israel do not exist in a vacuum. Anti-Jewish hatred has surged around the world, fueled in part by these false and inflammatory charges. When influential artists amplify these accusations to millions of followers, they lend them credibility and help create an environment in which Jews are increasingly vilified, harassed, and targeted.

We do not question Shawn’s compassion for Palestinian civilians or his desire to alleviate their suffering. But compassion without context is not education. Amplifying a narrative without understanding its origins, including the role of Hamas and its disinformation campaign, is irresponsible.

If Shawn is genuinely committed to educating himself, we encourage him to engage with Israelis, Palestinians, Jewish voices, and credible sources across the spectrum, rather than relying solely on those who reinforce what he already believes or belong to the anti-Israel movement.

The entertainment community has an enormous capacity to promote understanding. It also has a responsibility to avoid amplifying misinformation and rhetoric that can fuel hatred. Having a public platform does not make someone an authority, and good intentions do not excuse misinformation.

Speaking up takes courage. Taking the time to understand what you’re speaking about takes responsibility.

We hope Shawn Mendes will do both. Creative Community for Peace would welcome the opportunity to engage with him, broaden his understanding of the conflict, and explore how he can use his platform to effect positive change.

Gene Simmons Calls for Action Against Hate at CCFP’s Gala: ‘We Cannot Be Passive’

Read the original article here.

“Hate spreads like a cancer, and we must stop the hatred now,” the rocker adds at an event that also recognized Erin Foster, Lynn Harris, Kevin Weaver and Ethiopia Habtemariam

Gene Simmons, Erin Foster and Lynn Harris were among the honorees at the Creative Community For Peace’s eighth annual Ambassadors of Peace gala in mid-October. The event, hosted by the entertainment non-profit CCFP, was attended by 600 artists and industry leaders, there to support the list of honorees that also included Atlantic Music Group President Kevin Weaver and Hybe America’s President of Music, Ethiopia Habtemariam.

“Hate spreads like a cancer, and we must stop the hatred now. Today,” Simmons said at the event. “And we cannot be passive about it.”

Simmons was joined at the event by his wife and actress Shannon Tweed-Simmons, as well as his Kiss co-founder, Paul Stanley. The rockstar stopped by to talk to TheWrap before the event, echoing his sentiments about the night and his award.

“Awards are nice, but it’s about something that’s important, which is, we’ve got to all remind ourselves we live on this planet,” Simmons said. “I don’t want to get too cornball. There’s a lot of hatred going on. We’ve got to stop that, and it’s easier if you’re Jewish to talk about Jewish hatred, or if you practice Islam, you can talk about Islamophobia, or if you’re gay … there’s a lot of hatred going on. We’ve got to stop that.”

Among the night’s honorees was “Nobody Wants This” creator Erin Foster, attending the event held exactly one week before the release of her show’s third season. Foster, a convert to Judaism, used part of her speech to thank the Jewish community and CCFP for their acceptance.

“I want to thank the community here who has welcomed me to learn and grow with you and never making me feel like I don’t belong,” she said.

Foster wasn’t the only honoree with a big release on the way. The event, hosted on Oct. 15, came just over a week before honoree Lynn Harris returned to superhero cinema for the first time since producing 2004’s “Blade Trinity” with DC’s horror feature “Clayface” — the top film at the box office for its opening weekend.

“We are in an epic battle against an algorithm fed by misplaced rage and misinformation,” Harris said at the event. “The power of CCFP begins with that algorithm, helping us understand and distinguish the difference between noise and reality and uniting leaders and storytellers and empowering and encouraging us to take back our narrative.”

Legendary producer Jerry Bruckheimer, Grammy-nominated artist Keri Hilson, former Paramount CEO Sherry Lansing, producer Matti Leshem and music execs Carianne Marshall and Simon Tikhman were among those who turned out to honor the night’s award recipients. Previous honorees at CCFP’s Ambassadors of Peace event include Eugene Levy, Diane Warren, Liev Schreiber, Scooter Braun and Mayim Bialik.

Several of the night’s speakers reflected on the climate of the past three years following the Oct. 7 attacks of 2023, speaking to the organization’s overall message of fostering peace.

“We are living through a time of pain and division and in our creative community we have a responsibility to listen carefully, make room for different experiences and remember the human beings behind every story,” Weaver said at the event. “We can disagree and still care deeply about each other. That is why the work CCFP matters so much.”

“I will always be about peace first,” Habtemariam added in her acceptance speech. “I won’t allow people to be bullies or treat others like they don’t matter.”

The post Gene Simmons Calls for Action Against Hate at CCFP’s Gala: ‘We Cannot Be Passive’ appeared first on TheWrap.

More Than 600 Artists and Entertainment Industry Leaders Honored Gene Simmons, Erin Foster, Kevin Weaver, Lynn Harris, and Ethiopia Habtemariam at Creative Community for Peace’s 8th Annual ‘Ambassadors of Peace’ Event

Speakers confronted rising antisemitism and called on the entertainment industry to use its influence to foster dialogue, education, and greater understanding.

LOS ANGELES (Oct. 21 2026) – Creative Community For Peace (CCFP), an entertainment industry non-profit organization, hosted its eighth annual “Ambassadors of Peace” (AOP) event to honor prominent entertainment industry leaders for their commitment to speaking out against hate and using arts and culture to bring people together, bridge divides, and effect positive change in the world.

This year’s honorees were Gene Simmons, Rock Icon & Multi-Hyphenate Businessman; Erin Foster, Actress, Producer, Writer (Nobody Wants This); Kevin Weaver, President, Atlantic Music Group; Lynn Harris, Producer (Clayface, The Notebook, Se7en, Boogie Nights, King Richard); and Ethiopia Habtemariam, President of Music, HYBE AMERICA. The event was held at the Beverly Hills residence of Aton Ben-Horin, Executive VP A&R, Warner Music Group, and CEO Plush Management.

Artists and entertainment leaders from across the industry were in attendance, including Jerry Bruckheimer, Producer, David Foster, Producer and Composer, Haim Saban, Chairman and CEO of Saban Capital Group, Jody Gerson, Chairman and CEO of Universal Music Publishing Group, Harvey Mason jr., CEO of the Recording Academy, Elliot Grainge, CEO of Atlantic Records, Gary Barber, CEO of Spyglass Media Group, Perry Farrell, Artist, Lawrence Bender, Producer, Emmanuelle Chriqui, Actress, Tom Corson, COO of Warner Music Group, Val Blavatnik, Managing Director of Warner Music Group, Michael Rotenberg, Founder and Partner at 3 Arts Entertainment, Mark Beaven,  Co-Founder & Co-CEO of Advanced Alternative Media; and David Zedeck, Global Co-Head of Music at UTA, among many others.

Previous Ambassadors of Peace honorees include Eugene Levy, Actor, Diane Warren, Songwriter, Liev Schreiber, Actor, Director and Producer, Ziggy Marley, Artist, Scooter Braun, Music Executive, Darren Star, Producer and Showrunner, Mayim Bialik, Actress, Writer and Host, Harvey Mason jr., CEO of the Recording Academy, Troy Carter, Founder of Q&A and Atom Factory, Ben Silverman, Chairman and Co-CEO of Propagate Content, Elliot Grainge, CEO of Atlantic Music Group, Bruce Resnikoff, President and CEO of Universal Music Enterprises, Blair Kohan, Partner and Board Member at UTA, Aaron Bay-Schuck, CEO and Co-Chairman of Warner Records, Kat Graham, Actress, Artist and UNHCR Goodwill Ambassador, Ezekiel Lewis, President of Epic Records, Afo Verde, Chairman and CEO of Sony Music Latin America, and Jacqueline Saturn, President of Virgin Music, among others, many of whom were in attendance this year.

Paying tribute to this year’s honorees were actress Shannon Tweed-Simmons, KISS co-founder Paul Stanley, producer Jerry Bruckheimer, Grammy-nominated singer-songwriter Keri Hilson, former Paramount Pictures Chair and CEO Sherry Lansing, producer Matti Leshem, music executive Simon Tikhman, and music executive Carianne Marshall.

CCFP Chairman and Co-Founder, David Renzer, opened the evening and said, “Slogans are not solutions and we have to remember that they have real consequences. We must emphasize facts over misinformation, context over caricatures, debate over demonization, human dignity over hatred.”

Ari Ingel, CCFP Executive Director, said, “The strength of CCFP comes from the members of the entertainment industry who care about standing against hate. In an industry that celebrates diversity we cannot stay silent when Jewish and Israeli creatives are being excluded.”

The evening featured heartfelt speeches from the honorees, each reflecting on their personal commitment to using their platforms to advance peace and unity.

Honoree Gene Simmons said, “Hate spreads like a cancer and we must stop the hatred now. Today. And we cannot be passive about it.”

Honoree Erin Foster said, “I want to thank the community here who has welcomed me to learn and grow with you and never making me feel like I don’t belong.”

Honoree Kevin Weaver said, “We are living through a time of pain and division and in our creative community we have a responsibility to listen carefully, make room for different experiences and remember the human beings behind every story. We can disagree and still care deeply about each other. That is why the work CCFP matters so much.”

Honoree Lynn Harris said, “We are in an epic battle against an algorithm fed by misplaced rage and misinformation. The power of CCFP begins with that algorithm, helping us understand and distinguish the difference between noise and reality and uniting leaders and storytellers and empowering and encouraging us to take back our narrative.”

Honoree Ethiopia Habtemariam said, “I will always be about peace first. I won’t allow people to be bullies or treat others like they don’t matter.”

While celebratory, the evening also offered a moment for reflection. Three years after the October 7 attacks, speakers reflected on the lasting impact on the Jewish community and the alarming rise in antisemitism, reaffirming their commitment to speaking out against hate, challenging misinformation, and using their platforms to bring people together.

Throughout the evening, speakers emphasized the responsibility of the entertainment community to stand against efforts to divide people and to use the reach of music, film, television, and storytelling to encourage dialogue and human connection.

What Does “Free Palestine” Really Mean?

WHAT DOES “FREE PALESTINE” REALLY MEAN?

THE ANTI-ISRAEL MOVEMENT WANTS “FREE PALESTINE” TO SOUND SIMPLE. IT ISN’T.

“Free Palestine” has become one of the most recognizable political slogans in the world.

It can express concern for Palestinian civilians.

It can express support for Palestinian statehood.

It can also express something much more sweeping and much darker.

So before repeating the slogan, there is a question worth asking:

What exactly does “Free Palestine” mean?

AN INTENTIONALLY AMBIGUOUS SLOGAN

As journalist Jordyn Tilchen has previously written, the phrase “Free Palestine” is far more complicated than it sounds.

Free Palestine from what?

What borders are being envisioned?

Who governs this Palestinian state?

What happens to Hamas?

Does “freedom” mean two states — Israel and Palestine — living alongside one another?

Does it mean one binational state?

Or does it mean a Palestinian state replacing Israel entirely?

These are not minor details. They determine what “Free Palestine” actually means, and its ambiguity is precisely what has made the slogan so effective.

THE SAME THREE WORDS CAN DESCRIBE VERY DIFFERENT FUTURES

Imagine four people chanting “Free Palestine.”

One wants more humanitarian aid.

One wants an end to the fighting.

One supports an independent Palestinian state alongside Israel.

One believes Israel should cease to exist.

They are saying exactly the same words.

They are describing fundamentally different outcomes.

That ambiguity is part of the slogan’s power, and part of why the Palestinian movement championed the phrase.

FOR JEWS, THIS AMBIGUITY IS NOT ABSTRACT

Israel is the world’s only Jewish-majority state.

For Jews, it represents Jewish self-determination in their indigenous homeland after centuries of persecution, expulsion, and statelessness.

So when someone demands that Palestine be “freed,” the unanswered question becomes deeply consequential:

What happens to Israel and its people in the future being imagined?

WHAT THE PHRASE MEANS TO THE LEADERS OF THE PALESTINIAN MOVEMENT

Clearly, not everyone chanting “Free Palestine” wants Israel destroyed.

But by and large, the Palestinian diaspora, Jewish Voice for Peace, Hamas, Students for Justice in Palestine, and those guiding the Palestinian movement around the world understand exactly what the term really means.

It’s the eradication of the world’s only Jewish state.

For example, the chant “From the river to the sea, Palestine will be free” in Arabic is actually “From the water to the water, Palestine will be Arab.”

The mistranslation in English is intentional.

REAL-LIFE CONSEQUENCES

The darker meaning of the phrase cannot simply be dismissed as Jewish oversensitivity.

The phrase “Free Palestine” has accompanied actual violence against Jews in the United States, Canada, the UK, Australia, and elsewhere around the world.

For instance, in Washington in 2025, police said the man accused of killing two people at an AJC event shouted “Free, free Palestine” after his arrest.

In Boulder, less than two weeks later, prosecutors said an attacker threw Molotov cocktails at a gathering supporting Israeli hostages while yelling “Free Palestine,” killing an 82-year-old Jewish woman.

LET’S TALK ABOUT MACKLEMORE

When Macklemore shouts “Free Palestine” into a stadium microphone and thousands of people shout it back, there is no reason to assume everyone in that stadium means the same thing.

Some may envision Israelis and Palestinians eventually living peacefully in two states.

Many others, probably including the artist himself, envision a future in which Israel no longer exists.

LET’S TALK ABOUT ZACH BRYAN

Zach Bryan took the stage at Gillette Stadium wearing a “Free Palestine” shirt.

What did he mean by it?

Perhaps he means freedom.

Perhaps he means peace.

Perhaps he means Palestinian rights.

Those may genuinely be his intentions.

But many people in the audience may interpret his statement very differently.

A SLOGAN CAN UNITE PEOPLE WHO ACTUALLY DISAGREE

That is what makes “Free Palestine” unusually effective as a political slogan.

It allows people with incompatible visions to stand together beneath the same words.

A supporter of coexistence can say it.

A supporter of two states can say it.

Someone who wants Israel dismantled can say it.

For a few seconds, they can appear to be demanding the same thing.

They are not necessarily demanding the same thing at all.

IF YOU MEAN PEACE, SAY IT

The leaders of the anti-Israel movement understand this, but do the people chanting it?

If you mean humanitarian aid, say it.

If you mean Palestinian self-determination, define it.

If you support two states living side by side, say it clearly.

And if the political vision requires the disappearance of Israel, that should be stated clearly too.

Palestinians deserve a future of dignity and self-determination.

Israelis deserve security and self-determination.

A serious conversation about peace has to make room for both peoples and reject a slogan that simply builds another barrier to peace.

Millions of parents trust Ms. Rachel. That trust comes with responsibility.

RACHEL HAS MILLIONS OF FOLLOWERS.
THEY DESERVE THE TRUTH.

Millions of parents and followers trust Ms. Rachel. With that trust comes responsibility.

When she shares claims about starving children in Gaza, the evidence deserves as much attention as the images.

Compassion matters. So does accuracy.

THE DEVASTATING IMAGES DON’T TELL THE REAL STORY.

Images of a few dozen severely malnourished children were circulated around the world as evidence of starvation in Gaza, but they omitted significant context.

As reported by The Free Press, images circulated by Ms. Rachel and others omitted critical information about the children’s underlying health conditions, such as cystic fibrosis, rickets and immune disorders.

Those children’s suffering was real. Sharing their images without medical context misled audiences.

THE CASE OF MARYAM DAWAS

One clear example of this deception.

In 2025, the Los Angeles Times described Maryam Dawas’s condition this way: “Doctors confirmed that her condition is solely the result of hunger and malnutrition.”

Her family’s subsequent fundraising campaign disclosed: “Maryam has a serious immune disorder that attacks her body every day, leaving her weak and vulnerable.”

Ms Rachel’s  audience deserved that information.

MS. RACHEL’S RESPONSE? “WHY DOES THAT EVEN MATTER?”

It matters.

A serious underlying medical condition can affect a child’s weight, appearance and nutritional vulnerability.

It matters when an image is presented to millions of people as evidence of population-wide starvation.

And it matters when those images contribute to accusations against Israel that reverberate around the world.

MS. RACHEL TALKS ABOUT STARVATION. HER AUDIENCE DESERVES THE ACTUAL DATA.

A UNICEF-led team published its latest comprehensive nutrition analysis of Gaza in July 2026.

Using weight-for-height measurements, researchers found acute malnutrition in just 0.5% of the children surveyed.

The survey also found stunting in about 12% of children surveyed.

That is less than the Middle East and North Africa’s 15% to 26% stunting rate, according to the latest report on child malnutrition by UNICEF, the World Health Organization, and the World Bank.

BUT THAT’S NOT ALL UNICEF FOUND

The UNICEF-led team’s presentation also revealed that Gaza now faces a new challenge: obesity and excess weight.

A leading researcher who has overseen teams collecting malnutrition data in the Horn of Africa remarked that she had “never seen” the emergence of obesity and excess weight in a place that was declared only a year earlier to be suffering from “famine.”

These findings paint a considerably more complicated picture than the one presented by Ms. Rachel and by the viral images.

THE WAY MALNUTRITION WAS MEASURED DURING THE WAR, WAS MISLEADING.

During the war, researchers said they had repeatedly been unable to collect weight-for-height data because of the conflict.

That meant assessments relied on the often inaccurate  mid-upper-arm circumference, or MUAC, measurements.

Those arm measurements identified more than twice as many cases than there actually were.

Yannay Spitzer, an applied economist in Boston, told The Free Press that the survey results show that the IPC’s famine declaration rested on an erroneous assumption that undermines its validity.

“It’s just another example of how flawed the methodology was.”

THE FAMINE THAT NEVER WAS

The famine narrative originated with reports from the IPC, a UN-aligned body working closely with several anti-Israel NGOs.

In March 2024, it predicted that Gaza would enter famine within four months, claiming that 39% of the population faced emergency-level food insecurity and another 30% had already reached catastrophic—or famine—levels.

Those claims were later rejected by the IPC’s own Famine Review Committee (FRC), an independent body tasked with evaluating IPC findings. In a June review, the FRC concluded it was “not plausible” that Gaza had entered famine.

Ms. Rachel never mentions any of this.

FAMINE HAS DEFINED CRITERIA.

There are three conditions that must be met for a food crisis to qualify as famine.

One of those requirements is that the death rate per day exceeds 2 deaths per 10,000 people overall or 4 deaths per 10,000 children under five.

In Gaza, that would have required the number of deaths due to famine reaching 440 people or 134 children under five, per day.

Nothing remotely approaching that occurred.

In September 2025, Al Jazeera reported a total of 361 malnutrition deaths over two years of war.

But the vast majority suffered from severe underlying health conditions.

MS. RACHEL AND THE IPC RELIED ON HAMAS

The IPC relied on Hamas-provided data that failed to account for private-sector food entering Gaza, ignored locally sourced food, and grossly overestimated the number of people located in areas it labeled at risk of famine.

For instance, the IPC again warned of famine conditions in parts of Gaza in August 2025 — claims that once more failed to materialize.

An October 2025 report by the Global Nutrition Cluster, which coordinates emergency nutrition responses, found that the malnutrition figures in Gaza were 23% lower than those used by the IPC.

This discrepancy stemmed from data manipulation, meaning the IPC’s own threshold for famine was not met.

MS. RACHEL WANTS HER AUDIENCE TO “SPEAK THE TRUTH.”


THAT STANDARD APPLIES TO HER, TOO.

The war in Gaza has caused tremendous suffering.

The public deserves more than viral photographs stripped of context and sweeping claims presented without scrutiny.

Every child deserves compassion.

Every humanitarian claim demands accuracy.

And an audience of millions deserves the full story.

WHO WAS ACTUALLY STARVING IN GAZA?

During the war, Israel facilitated nearly 1.87 million tons of aid into Gaza. After the October 2025 ceasefire, another 1.78+ million tons of food has entered, three times what the World Food Programme said was needed.

The Hostages Were the Ones Actually Famished

Former hostage Evyatar David, among the last captives freed, was filmed by Hamas digging his own grave. “You can see my body, I could barely move.” He and Guy Gilboa-Dalal “didn’t eat for three months.”

As he struggled, he could hear his guards “laughing, eating cakes and drinking tea.”

“They told us there is no food in Gaza, but we knew it’s not true, because we always saw the terrorists – they were fat and had muscles. We knew they were lying and starving us.”

X