Skip to main content
All Posts By

CCFPeace

EXCLUSIVE: Billie Eilish becomes victim of ‘manufactured outrage’: Singer’s Instagram was targeted by anti-Semitic bots and trolls after she promoted her new album on MTV Israel, report reveals

  • A new social media analysis shows Billie Eilish’s Instagram account was targeted by anti-Semitic bots and trolls after she promoted her new album on MTV Israel
  • The 19-year-old pop singer released a video to her Israeli audience on July 31, announcing the release of her second studio album, Happier Than Ever
  • Her account was then ‘flooded with thousands of bot-driven comments consisting of Palestinian flags and other Palestine solidarity-themed comments’
  • A report by pro-Israel organization titled ‘Manufactured Outrage’ obtained by DailyMail.com  six posts Eilish made between July 31 and August 5 
  • Among the top comments, 30 per cent were anti-Israel and posted by users with no posts on their personal profile (a strong indicator of bot activity)
  • Director Ari Ingel told DailyMail.com it’s ‘difficult to say for certain’ who’s behind the attacks, but the CCFP suspects ‘state actors’ including Iran
  • ‘These are fraudulent accounts, carrying out coordinated Anti-Israel campaigns by actors who have one goal, and that’s to demonize and delegitimize Israel,’ he said

Billie Eilish was targeted by armies of anti-Semitic bots and trolls online after promoting her new album on MTV Israel, a new social media analysis found.

The 19-year-old pop singer made a series of promotional videos for her second studio album, Happier Than Ever, each tailored to a different country, following its July 30 release.

She shared a clip on July 31 aimed at her Israeli audience, saying ‘Hi Israel, I’m so excited that my new album, ‘Happier Than Ever,’ is out now.’

Her Instagram account was then ‘flooded with thousands of bot-driven comments consisting of Palestinian flags and other Palestine solidarity-themed comments’, according to a report – titled ‘Manufactured Outrage’ – by pro-Israel organization Creative Community for Peace (CCFP).

CCFP study obtained by DailyMail.com analyzed six of Eilish’s posts after she put out her ‘Hi Israel’ video.

A new social media analysis shows Billie Eilish's Instagram account was targeted by anti-Semitic bots and trolls after she promoted her new album on MTV Israel

A new social media analysis shows Billie Eilish’s Instagram account was targeted by anti-Semitic bots and trolls after she promoted her new album on MTV Israel.

The 19-year-old pop singer appeared in a July 31 video (pictured) aimed at her Israeli audience, saying 'Hi Israel, I'm so excited that my new album, 'Happier Than Ever,' is out now'

The 19-year-old pop singer appeared in a July 31 video (pictured) aimed at her Israeli audience, saying ‘Hi Israel, I’m so excited that my new album, ‘Happier Than Ever,’ is out now’

Among the top comments, 30 per cent were anti-Israel and posted by users with no posts on their personal profile (a strong indicator of bot activity). Those comments received 235,995 likes. Another 12 percent were posted by users with only one or two posts on their profiles.

The report describes the onslaught of anti-Israel and pro-Palestine comments as a ‘coordinated attack on Billie Eilish’ and a ‘specific effort by anti-Israel activists, who use social media to distort and influence public opinion against Israel via inauthentic means.’

Billie's second studio album Happier Than Ever was released on July 30

Billie’s second studio album Happier Than Ever was released on July 30

‘Bot armies attacked Billie Eilish’s Instagram account with waves of sock-puppet and fake account posts. This was done in an effort to overtake her influential social media page and to use it as their own bully pulpit,’ the report said.

‘The frequency and volume of the comments creates a false impression. The overwhelming presence of the comments on the videos intended to silence her from ever mentioning Israel again and to give a false impression to her fans that thousands of real people are posting comments on her posts.’

The study also highlighted reports of ‘Iranian troll farms run by the Iranian government’ which ‘amplified anti-Israel and anti-Semitic messages during the recent Israel-Hamas conflict in May, including the phrases ‘Hitler was right’ and ‘kill all Jews’ at a rate of 175 times per minute.’

CCFP director Ari Ingel told DailyMail.com that although it is ‘difficult to say for certain’ who is behind the reported social media attacks, they suspect ‘state actors’ including Iran.

A report obtained by DailyMail.com analyzed the star's Instagram comments after the release of the video and showed her account was flooded with anti-Israel and pro-Palestine comments

A report obtained by DailyMail.com analyzed the star’s Instagram comments after the release of the video and showed her account was flooded with anti-Israel and pro-Palestine comments

Pro-Israel organization Creative Community for Peace (CCFP) found 30 per cent of her top comments across six posts had anti-Israel sentiments and were posted by users with no posts on their personal profile (a strong indicator of bot activity)

Creative Community for Peace (CCFP) found 30 per cent of her top comments across six posts had anti-Israel sentiments and were posted by users with no posts on their personal profile (a strong indicator of bot activity)

Eilish posted a photo of herself with friends on the same day her video was released, attracting an onslaught of pro-Palestine comments

Eilish posted a photo of herself with friends on the same day her video was released, attracting an onslaught of pro-Palestine comments

Pictured above are the comments left by Palestinian bots on the July 31 post and the number of likes they received

Pictured above are the comments left by Palestinian bots on the July 31 post and the number of likes they received

CCFP analyzed 468 comments and the profiles that made them, noting the number of likes and replies on each, and the number of posts and followers the accounts had. The majority of accounts did not have any posts on their profile

CCFP analyzed 468 comments and the profiles that made them, noting the number of likes and replies on each, and the number of posts and followers the accounts had. The majority of accounts did not have any posts on their profile

‘One thing is clear, it’s not fans of Billie Eilish, or fans of music in general,’ he said.

‘These are fraudulent accounts, carrying out coordinated Anti-Israel campaigns by actors who have one goal, and that’s to demonize and delegitimize Israel.

‘What’s striking is the sheer volume, frequency, and level of coordination we’re seeing. The people and state actors behind these campaigns understand how social media algorithms work,’ he added.

‘These attacks are very calculated as thousands of fraudulent comments flood profiles with negative comments, and then bots give these comments thousands of ‘likes’ to get them into the top slots of a post.

‘In terms of volume, 48 per cent of the ‘top comments’ of the posts we examined that were distinctly anti-Israel, shockingly garnered almost 300,000 likes.

‘That demonstrates an incredibly high-level of coordination and operational capacity. It’s disturbing that social media outlets are not doing more to crackdown on this behavior and disinformation.

‘We have seen a rise in coordinated, strategic social media campaigns to defame Israel and to bully public figures that simply mention Israel in any sort of positive light.’

The report found 48 per cent of the 'top comments' of the posts examined were distinctly anti-Israel and garnered almost 300,000 likes

The report found 48 per cent of the ‘top comments’ of the posts examined were distinctly anti-Israel and garnered almost 300,000 likes

The study, titled, 'Manufactured Outrage' listed a number of 'bot' accounts that attacked the singer's Instagram 'with waves of sock-puppet and fake account posts'

The study, titled, ‘Manufactured Outrage’ listed a number of ‘bot’ accounts that attacked the singer’s Instagram ‘with waves of sock-puppet and fake account posts’

Billie Eilish at the 2021 Met Gala celebrating 'In America: A Lexicon of Fashion' on September 13 in NYC

Billie Eilish at the 2021 Met Gala celebrating ‘In America: A Lexicon of Fashion’ on September 13 in NYC

The report covered six Instagram posts Eilish made between July 31 and August 5, following the release of her ‘Hi Israel’ video.

CCFP analyzed 468 comments and the profiles that made them, noting the number of likes and replies on each, and the number of posts and followers the accounts had.

Of the 468 top comments, 123 or 26 per cent were deemed anti-Israel or pro-Palestinian by CCFP’s study and were made by accounts with no posts on their profiles.

The comments received a total 217,269 likes. The top ‘bot’ comment received 13,317 likes.

A further 47 comments were made by accounts that only had one or two posts on their personal profiles and were labelled ‘suspected bots’ by CCFP.

CCFP has worked with celebrities including Michael Bublé, Sherry Lansing, Gene Simmons, Meghan McCain and Selma Blair.

The organization is opposed to the ‘Boycott, Divestment and Sanctions’ movement that targets Israel, and was founded with the purpose of helping artists and performers with navigating appearances in Israel.

Diane Warren, Harvey Mason Jr., Post Malone’s Manager Among Honorees at Creative Community for Peace Fundraiser

By: Roy Trakin

On a cool, fall October night, the Creative Community for Peace (CCFP) held its third annual “Ambassadors of Peace” fundraising event to a backyard full of smiles. After taking a year off for the pandemic, the music industry came out in force to support the organization that has tried to counteract calls to boycott Israel by encouraging artists and creatives across entertainment to learn more about the region and performing in the country.

CCFP launched in 2018 with inaugural honorees Scooter Braun, then Geffen Records chief Neil Jacobson and Warner Music Group A&R executive Aton Ben-Horin. This year’s diverse crop of honorees included Recording Academy CEO Harvey Mason jr., hit songwriter Diane Warren, Sony Music Latin America, Spain & Portugal chairman/CEO Afo Verde, Columbia Records SVP A&R/Unrestricted President Ben Madahhi, Co-Star Entertainment president Traci Szymanski, and Electric Feel Entertainment founder/CEO Austin Rosen. (Watch Post Malone, a management client at Electric Feel, congratulate Rosen via video above.)

“Music is a powerful force for diplomacy,” said publishing vet David Renzer, co-founder of CCFP with EA’s Steve Schnur (the latter was not in attendance), revealing the evening will raise more than $300k for the organization. “We’re trying to use the arts to build those bridges, to remind ourselves of those commonalities and symbiotic relationships.”

The previous two sold-out events were held at the Hancock Park home of entertainment attorney Aaron Rosenberg and TV producer Danny Rose, and the home of lawyer Gary Stiffelman and wife Carmen, but this year’s edition was at the Beverly Hills residence of honoree Ben Madahhi’s parents, his father — a cardiology doctor at UCLA who fled Iran for the U.S. in 1975 — and mother beaming on the black carpet.

“This has a deep meaning to me because I grew up an Iranian-American Jew in Los Angeles, with both Muslim and Jewish friends,” said Ben Madahhi from the podium. “Music has the power to heal, to unite people and eliminate divisiveness. My parents raised me to have respect for people of all different backgrounds and cultures. My mission has always been to make records that uplift and unite people, have a positive impact.”

For honoree Diane Warren, the appeal of the organization was simple. “Any organization that is about peace and supports Israel, I’m good with,” said the award-winning songwriter. “Anti-Semitism always seems to rear its ugly head, and it seems more prevalent than ever.”

Ari Ingel, who quit practicing law to become director of CCFP, noted that, due to the pandemic, which had people glued to their computers, there was a rise in the kind of misinformation which fuels prejudice.

“We have a great deal of work to do,” insisted Ingel. “There are more people than ever spreading misinformation and outright lies. Our goal is to educate the industry and the public to counter those falsehoods.  Unfortunately, it’s far from being eradicated.”

The organization was founded against the backdrop of musicians like Roger Waters, formerly of Pink Floyd, advocating for the policy of BDS (which stands for boycott, divestment and sanctions), and Lana Del Rey pulling out of a scheduled festival performance there after much outside pressure.

“The last Gaza conflict between Israel and Hamas brought out a lot of haters,” said Ingel. “Events like this encourage an open discussion of the issues, and how we can use our voices to effect positive change.”

Austin Rosen, whose Electric Feel Entertainment represents management clients like Post Malone, 24KGoldn and Iann Dior — Dior showed up in support along with hitmakers Louis Bell, Billy Walsh and Blake Slatkin — is planning on opening a recording studio in Tel Aviv and promises his acts (like Post Malone) will tour there. “It’s all about awareness, making people understand it’s OK to play there,” offered the press-shy entrepreneur.

Lazy loaded image

Grammy chief Harvey Mason Jr., who was introduced by his Recording Academy colleague Jimmy Jam (pictured above) — almost unrecognizable after a 120-pound weight loss — said of the honor:

“For me, it’s bringing people together, coming from a place of peace and love,” said Mason jr., whose efforts to diversify his organization’s membership and making the Grammy voting process more transparent have not gone unnoticed. “Political and religious beliefs may be all over the map, but my goal is to be productive, make things better rather than dividing and separating us from one another.

“I sympathize with any group that’s been discriminated against or persecuted. I try to support unifying, not battling one another. The power of music can unite us in a time where it’s most needed.”

The individual speeches were preceded by a taped message of support from Clive Davis, then followed by musical performances from Columbia Records artist Clinton Kane, a singer-songwriter who played his hit “Chicken Tendies,” followed by Deborah Cox who delivered a pitch-perfect rendition of “Imagine” that fit the hopeful mood.

It was left to Jimmy Jam, admitting he was just glad to be around people again, to sum up the evening’s goals. “What’s important is music and community,” he told Variety. “Music heals, it’s the soundtrack to our lives. Music is uplifting, it’s a divine art. It just makes things a little better.

Pictured (from left): Austin Rosen, Afo Verde, Diane Warren, Harvey Mason Jr. and Ben Madahhi

Read the original article on Variety.com here.

X